top of page
Search

Understanding martial arts: What remains when the technique doesn't work?

Writer: GM Thomas Schrön
GM Thomas Schrön
Sep 11
5 min read

Updated: Sep 14

Those who only learn techniques need an answer for every problem.

Those who understand impact can develop answers themselves.


In martial arts, we spend a great deal of time focusing on techniques.


What do I do against a punch? How do I break a hold? How do I react to pressure? What is the right movement for this or that situation?


That is understandable. Techniques are concrete. They can be demonstrated, practiced, repeated, and corrected. But eventually, there comes a point when a technique doesn't work the way it is supposed to.


The training partner is bigger, heavier, or faster, or reacts differently than expected. The distance is off. The angle shifts. The pressure comes from a different direction. Or, quite simply, they don't do what we need them to do for our movement at that moment. And then?


For me, this is where one of the most interesting questions in martial arts arises.


Eye-level view of a martial arts training session with Grandmaster Thomas Schrön
Training session with Grandmaster Thomas Schrön

Understanding Martial Arts Changes the Way We Train

A technique is initially just a solution.


Problems arise when we start equating the technique with the solution. After all, any technique only works under specific conditions. Distance, timing, structure, the direction of force, and the movement itself must all align. If one of these conditions changes, the outcome changes as well.


In training, I often see movements being corrected by trying to replicate their external form more precisely.

The arm goes here. The elbow goes there. The hips must move in this way.


That may be necessary. But sometimes, the error does not lie where we see it. Perhaps the distance is wrong. Perhaps one's force isn't reaching the intended point of impact. Perhaps the structure collapsed beforehand. Perhaps the correct movement is simply being executed at the wrong time.

In such cases, replicating the technique more precisely does little to help.


We need to understand why it is failing to produce the desired effect.


Impact is the decisive benchmark.


In my teaching, I am therefore increasingly less interested in the name of a movement. I am interested in what it achieves.


What change does it bring about in the other person? Where does pressure arise? Where does it dissipate? What structure supports the movement? How is force transmitted? What distance do I need? How does the angle change things? And what happens when my partner does exactly what I didn't expect?


These questions move us beyond mere imitation. They lead to understanding.


In doing so, I consistently focus on six areas: structure, force, movement, timing, distance, and strategy. While they can be examined individually, they work in concert during actual application. Excellent structure is of little use if the distance is wrong. Force without timing is wasted. A fast movement can be ineffective if it is directed the wrong way. And a technically flawless action can still be the wrong strategic choice. That is precisely why simply knowing a movement is not enough.


You have to understand what makes it work.


What happens if the other person doesn't play along?


A dangerous sense of security can arise during training.


Attack A is met with response B. Then comes C. The training partner knows the sequence and unconsciously facilitates the exact situation required for our technique. The result looks good.


But we may have trained something that only works as long as both parties stick to the same agreement.


A real-world conflict involves no such agreement.

The opponent does not know our technique. He does not know our sequence. And above all, he has absolutely no interest in providing the conditions under which our movement works best.


That is why training must eventually allow for the question:

What happens if things go differently?


To me, this does not represent a failure of the technique. Quite the opposite.

It is an opportunity to discover what we have actually understood.


Principles create freedom.


Once I understand why something works, I am no longer completely bound by its external form. I can make changes.


I can adapt. I can recognize that the same effect might be achieved through a different movement—or that a movement which was correct in a specific situation no longer makes sense just a few centimeters or a fraction of a second later.


This does not mean treating techniques arbitrarily, nor does it mean that fundamentals become unimportant. Quite the opposite: the more precisely I understand the fundamentals, the less I need to cling to a prescribed form. For me, this is a crucial distinction between merely being able to do something and truly understanding it.

The better question is often: Why?


After many years of practicing martial arts, one’s perspective shifts.


At first, you want to know: What do I have to do?

Later, other questions become more interesting: Why does this work?

Under what conditions does it work? When does it stop working? And: What needs to change to make it effective again?

This is the point where martial arts become particularly fascinating to me.


Suddenly, a technique that doesn't work is no longer just a nuisance to be corrected as quickly as possible; it becomes a tool for analysis.


When something fails to work, it reveals that a necessary condition is missing somewhere. I have to figure out which one. To do this, I must observe, experiment, make adjustments, and re-evaluate the outcome. It is an ongoing process.


And perhaps that is precisely one of the reasons why, even after decades, one never truly finishes learning martial arts.


Understanding changes training.


That is why I do not want to give my students a ready-made answer for every conceivable situation. That would be impossible anyway. The number of possible situations, people, distances, reactions, and dynamics is virtually limitless. For me, something else is crucial:


A student should learn to recognize for themselves why something works—or why it doesn't. That transforms their ability to act. They no longer wait to retrieve the right technique from memory; instead, they can perceive what is actually happening and adjust their actions accordingly. This takes time. It requires good training.


And it requires the willingness to let a technique deliberately fail—and to take a close look at it—rather than immediately prescribing the next solution.


For that is precisely where the greatest insight is often gained.


So what remains when the technique doesn't work?

The principles. The understanding of structure, power, movement, timing, distance, and strategy. And the ability to let a new solution emerge from that understanding. Techniques remain important. They are an essential part of our training and development. But for me, they are not the end of learning. They are the beginning of a question:


Why does this work?


Anyone who finds increasingly better answers to that question eventually stops merely collecting techniques.


They begin to understand martial arts.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page